Showing posts with label GRDG534. Show all posts
Showing posts with label GRDG534. Show all posts

April 13, 2007

Tangerine - Part 3

I’ve left Paul Fisher hanging since March 11 – let’s see what he’s been up to.

What we last checked in, Paul had become a War Eagle at Tangerine High. He certified his membership when, after getting mud smeared in his eyes, he jumped on the back of the perpetrator and commenced punching him in the head. This event served as Paul’s unplanned, but not unwanted, full initiation into the team.

Part 2 ended with Lake Windsor High and Tangerine High battling to a season-ending tie, giving the league championship to the War Eagles. Paul ended the season in goal, right where he always wanted to be. Part 3 is all about Paul’s transformation, growth and what could even be termed a re-birth. His feeling of community with the War Eagles extends to helping during a hard freeze that threatens the Cruz family citrus groves. Paul works all night to keep the smudge fires burning and the trees coated with protective ice, and becomes more and more a part of the Cruz – War Eagles clan.

The incident that triggers the final step in Paul’s transformation is when he secretly witnesses Luis Cruz being assaulted by Arthur Bauer. When Luis dies as a result six days later, events accelerate as the story comes full circle. As a fitting punishment for their abuse of Mike Costello’s brother and Luis’ assault, Erik Fisher and Arthur Bauer are attacked and beaten by Victor and Tino at a ceremony in honor of Mike. Wow – I think I need a scorecard. Paul helps Tino escape when he jumps on Coach Warner’s back. This particular action did however have a downside. While Paul earned the further respect of the Cruz family and the students of Tangerine High, it also led to his expulsion from the school.

After Paul explains the truth about Erik and Arthur, his transformation continues when he stands up to them outside the walls of Lake Windsor Downs, and the memories come back about his eye injury. It wasn’t a #@%& solar eclipse! It was Erik and another one of his goons who sprayed paint in Paul’s eyes. He wasn’t a dumb kid who stared at the sun – he was the victim of his parents protecting their older child. Finally he knew.

Paul’s final step to believing in himself comes on his last visit to Tangerine High. The other students knew he stood up for what was right, he stood up for Luis, and he stood up for telling the truth. Even though he would be heading to his third school this year, Paul Fisher grew into himself. He did more than come out from his brother’s shadow – Paul learned that Erik wasn’t enough of a person to even cast a shadow.

March 27, 2007

Thesis-Support Microtheme

Thesis:
The media consistently promotes the myth of the classless society.

Summary:
Mass media, and especially television, is used to promote the idea that “the rich are just like us”, they have the same problems, they are all hard working, they face significant personal and professional issues, and the money they have doesn’t really mean much to them. They are friends to all of us, and there are no divisions of wealth or class to separate “us” from “them”.

Supporting Evidence (from Hooks, Bell – Where we stand: class matters):
Daytime and nighttime soap operas depict the lives of the rich as one sad crisis after another. They have numerous personal problems that all the money in the world will not cure.
The rich are also depicted in television shows are extremely hard working, just as any cook, janitor, or blue collar worker.
Most television shows promote the sense that nearly everyone is well-off, or will be very soon. They spend their money freely on material goods, and we can be more like them and feel closer to them if we purchase the same products. We have an equal right to purchase anything we want, just like the rich.
We live in a classless, consumerism-based society. You can demonstrate your individualism by purchasing exactly the same consumer goods as the well-to-do everyone sees on TV.
Celebrity television shows us a way to identify with the rich. If we can identify with them, we can demonstrate that they are like us, and we are like them. We buy the same consumer products; we have the same trials and tribulations; we feel the same pain.
When we hear the rich talk about their lives, we feel a sense of intimacy with them. When I see a picture of a rich celebrity having a “bad hair” day in a magazine, I feel like we are similar.
The rich are eager to cross class boundaries, and are open, kind, and vulnerable.

March 11, 2007

Tangerine - Part 2

OK, so Paul Fisher got his new start at Tangerine High in Part 2. He’s on the soccer team and playing backup goalie – right where he wanted to be. We learn about the power structure on the Tangerine War Eagles, and the power begins and ends with Victor. It’s a small team with only fifteen players, about half the size of the Seagulls at Lake Windsor Middle.

Paul’s initiation into how the game is played doesn’t take long. After Tino is thrown out of the first game against Palmetto Middle School, Coach Bright puts him in, but NOT in goal! No matter, and Paul doesn’t let on he’s never considered anything but goal. Unfortunately he blows a big chance for the tying goal, which is followed by a friendly death threat from Victor.

We see something really unexpected from Paul when right after he blows the chance for the goal and gets Victor’s reminder that he blew it and it could cost them the game, someone smears mud in HIS EYES! Paul goes nuts, jumps on the players back and starts punching away, a la Tino. So ends Paul’s playing time in game number one, but his fight earned him respect and made him one of the War Eagles, not to be messed with. Is this the real Paul coming out, fitting right in with the War Eagles?

We see a glimpse of evil in Erik and his friend Arthur when they see Paul’s friend Joey, calling him “Mohawk Man’s brother”. Mohawk Man is a reference to Joey’s dead brother Mike, who had half his hair burned off his head by the lightning strike that killed him. Nice boys they are, that Erik and Arthur. I have a feeling we’ll see just how evil Arthur might be later in the book.

Paul tries very hard to help out his friend Joey, and convinces him to transfer to Tangerine with him so he can be in the same classes and on the soccer team. This does not go well at all, and we find that Joey’s anger (certainly connected to his brother’s tragic death) is directed at everyone, including Paul. Joey needs the comfort, familiarity, predictability, and blandness of Lake Windsor Downs and Lake Windsor Middle School.

February 20, 2007

Post Reading Strategy - Mind Map

Tovani Chapter 5 – “Why Am I Reading This?"


During Reading Strategy - Text Coding

Tovani Chapter 6 - "Holding Thinking To Remember and Reuse"

Text coding is a quick way for students to become conscious of and to record mental responses to their reading. (Daniels & Zemelman, "Subjects Matter")

Here is my personalized version of text codes, along with two sample pages from Tovani:






Pre-Reading Strategy - Anticipation Guide

Tovani Chapter 5 – “Why Am I Reading This?"

1) Pretend you are asking your students the following questions:

- Have you ever been assigned a reading, and before you even started, you were asking yourself “Why am I reading this?” or “Why do we have to read this?”

- Have you ever started reading something and wondered “Why am I reading this?” or “What does THIS have to do with any part of my real life?”

What do you think their answers would be?

2) When you assign your students a reading, do you have difficulty deciding what the instructional focus should be? In other words, what is their purpose for the reading?


3) When you begin a reading for yourself, do you know your purpose? Do you have an unconscious, unstated purpose?


4) What do you think happens when your students don’t have a purpose for their reading?

February 19, 2007

Tangerine - Part 1


Part 1 of Tangerine was WILD! Was this a dream come true? – the earth opened up and swallowed Paul’s classroom! This was the ULTIMATE snow day, snow week, and snow month rolled into one!

Now of course we are all dedicated and passionate learners, and we wouldn’t really hope that our school would fall into a hole, and we know it would be expensive, and we wouldn’t want anyone to get hurt, but….

Tangerine IS weirder than it looks, and smells, and sounds, and feels. I can smell the muck fires burning, I can see the thunderstorms building, I can hear the earth opening up, I can feel the sorrow of the Costellos when they lose their son. I can also feel the hope for a new start that Paul feels when he sees the opportunity to leave the strangeness of Lake Windsor Middle School, and his IEP, behind him for Tangerine Middle.

I made two moves when I was a kid. The first one was when I was in first grade, and the way I felt is still with me. Everyone was new, I was nerdy, I was picked on. I still remember one kid, named Bobby, who used to pick a fight with me every day as soon as we crossed the street on the way home. I still get that sick feeling in my stomach when I think about it, and that first move happened in 1964.

I think Paul has his Bobby, or I had my Erik. The person you hated to see, but you knew he wouldn’t go away. He would be there every day waiting to make himself feel better by making you feel worse. The crazy thing is I ended up having Bobby for a friend several years later, but what happened after that I don’t recall. I made another move to a new school in seventh grade and maybe he disappeared from my life then.

Paul Fisher is going to get a new start, on his own terms, at Tangerine Middle.

February 6, 2007

A Balanced Diet

My reading diet has reasonable balance, but usually tends toward progressive politics, driven by the ever expanding disasters in the Middle East and at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue.

However, back home in the world of math and science, I have my own example similar to the exiting storyline that was developed for the book E=MC2, as described in D&Z chapter 4.

One of my favorite books, which I have read at least 3 times since it was published in 1986, is by Richard Rhodes and is titled The Making of The Atomic Bomb. It is non-fiction, supported by hundreds of notes and references, but describes the exciting story of the history of modern physics. As you might expect, the excerpt from D&Z describing Lise Meitner's breakthrough thinking regarding atomic fission is also described in Rhodes' book, although more extensively but with similar passion.

The reading prompted me to pull out this book off the shelf and quote MY favorite part, which begins the book.

In London, where Southampton Row passes Russell Square, across from the British Museum in Bloomsbury, Leo Szilard waited irritably one gray Depression morning for the stoplight to change. A trace of rain had fallen during the night; Tuesday, September 12, 1933, dawned cool, humid, and dull. Drizzling rain would begin again in early afternoon. When Szilard told the story later he never mentioned his destination that morning. He may have had none; he often walked to think. In any case another destination intervened. The stoplight changed to green. Szilard stepped off the curb. As he crossed the street, time cracked open before him and he saw a way to the future, death into the world and all our woe, the shape of things to come.


And the book then leaves you hanging by shifting to Szilard's background and what brought him to that morning's walk. We don't find out for several hundred pages that what Szilard saw in his mind's eye as he crossed the street was the notion of an atomic chain reaction. It was this leap that led directly to the development of nuclear fission and atomic weaponry.

This text has nearly 800 pages of exciting but accurate descriptions of many scenes related to mathematics and physics, and would be a great source of excerpts for secondary level classes.

January 30, 2007

I HATE TEXTBOOKS!

OK, maybe hate is too strong a word - how about "My experience with recent high school textbooks agrees with Daniels and Zemelman's thinking that Textbooks are Not Enough"?
The example I'm most familiar with from the modern textbook world could have been the example cited in D&Z, which came from an American Association for the Advancement of Science study (Budiansky 2001). The study uses the adjective "hyperkinetic" to describe recent textbook, an apt description that brings to mind excessive or abnormal motion, spasms, and webpage hyperlinking, as in jumping from topic to topic.
The photo is an example from Prentice Hall's New York Math A text, which is one of the texts in use in my student teaching classroom. It has many of the hallmarks of a hyperkinetic text, including lots of color, photos (taking up lots of space while providing no content), a barely related sidebar, in this case a "Technology Hint" meant more as teacher guidance, and a "Try This!" section.

My reaction when I first opened this book was to be confused and overwhelmed, exactly as described by Daniels and Zemelman. The customers for this book (the students, not the textbook adoption committee) must feel at least as overwhelmed, videogame junkies or not. It took quite a while to be able to pull any sensible content out of this monster, and in another point of agreement with D&Z, it jumped from topic to topic almost randomly.

Did the textbook designers and salespeople have actual use in mind, or just sales? Another great observation from D&Z - You never want to see sausages, laws, or textbooks being made! Because the students aren't the customers - the textbook adoption committees in Texas and California are the people that must be served (along with the NYS committees for the our "personalized" version).

But wait! I have good news, in this case at least. The class I am teaching uses this book very sparingly. There is a class set that remains on the bookshelf, and the lessons are taught using the NYS standards aas guidance. Just about the only aspect of this resource that is used are the practice problem sheets from the associated workbooks.

I am in a school that seems to be adhering to the advice provided by D&Z - use textbooks sparingly (as reference books), and provide lots of authentic non-fiction readings - students should be reading the same books adults read. Who knew?